talk · Thursday 24 September · 09:03–⁠09:17 · SAL B

Beyond Data Integration: Ecological and Semantic Interoperability in Coastal Digital Twins

Laura Slaughter · Operationalizing Biodiversity Digital Twins within Data Space Ecosystems

Recording time 59:26–1:14:49Open on Vimeo ↗

Summaries and key moments are machine-produced. Check the recording for the speaker’s exact words.

The short versionCoastal digital twins expose a long list of unresolved land-sea interoperability gaps, from vertical datums and shifting shorelines to missing cross-domain ontologies.

Overview

What this was about

Laura Slaughter presented a landscape analysis of how far existing standards, data models and interoperability approaches support integrating land and sea data for coastal digital twins, and where the gaps remain. She distinguished digital models, digital shadows (what most demonstrators actually are) and full bidirectional digital twins, noting that SINTEF aims for 'learning twins' that can amend model structure. She then ran through categories of land-sea problems: spatial reference and boundaries (horizontal CRS and vertical datum mismatches, shoreline and boundary definitions), scale and resolution, semantic interoperability, units, technical interoperability, missing data (the 'white ribbon'), provenance and governance.

Why it matters. Anyone building digital twins that span terrestrial and marine domains will hit these problems; a structured map of existing support and gaps helps decide where to invest.

Key ideas

In the room

  • Norway's long coastline has produced several coastal twin projects (coastal change, storm simulators), where marine and terrestrial data 'clash'.
  • Work was a landscape analysis: derive digital twin requirements from the literature, then map land-sea integration problems, who works on them and remaining gaps.
  • Digital model (no automated link), digital shadow (automatically updated from the physical system but not acting back) and digital twin (bidirectional) are distinct; many demonstrators are shadows.
  • The goal is learning twins that can recommend interventions and amend both state and model structure, which raises requirements such as dynamic data integration and handling missing data.
  • Spatial issues: horizontal CRS mismatches (partly addressed, e.g. by OGC), vertical datum mismatch between land elevation and marine depth, dynamic shorelines, land-sea boundary semantics and geometry mismatches.
  • Semantic issues: incomplete cross-domain feature mappings, one concept with different names or definitions, need for cross-domain ontologies; units remain a problem.
  • Technical issues include schema, format and API incompatibilities; static integration becomes outdated, so dynamic integration with minimal information loss is needed.
Jump in

Notable moments

In their words

Transcript

Automatically generated captions can contain mistakes, especially in names and technical terms. Times are relative to the room recording.

Read the transcript ↓
Loading transcript…
Programme abstract

Beyond Data Integration: Ecological and Semantic Interoperability in Coastal Digital Twins

Laura Slaughter

Coastal zones are highly complex environments that are increasingly affected by sea-level rise, erosion, extreme weather events, biodiversity loss, pollution, and intensifying human activity. The development of coastal zone digital twins brings together diverse data types stemming from multiple domains, including marine science, urban planning, ecology, shipping, fisheries, climate science, and disaster management. The perspectives of these different disciplines and their respective data governance regimes collide, resulting in data integration challenges.

The paper presents a map of coastal zone semantic interoperability challenges, situated in relation to international frameworks including the EIF - European Interoperability Framework. Examples are drawn from a demonstrator twin for Oslofjord, where data is combined from diverse cross-disciplinary observation systems and governance domains. We have organized our map into different classes of problem-types, along with suggestions for tooling and potential solutions. We provide a concrete, practical overview of issues encountered by twin developers, spanning from problematic definitions and ontology misalignment, to inconsistent classifications, divergent coordinate reference systems, fundamental differences in spatial representation, separate metadata standards, temporal mismatches, as well as the limitations of available ontologies. We further cover the non-technical challenges, such as those related to uneven adoption of standards.

The work lays the foundation towards our main goal, “How do we enable a new generation of environmental digital twins that seamlessly integrate biodiversity data between marine, coastal, and terrestrial ecosystems of twins?”

Submitted to the conference programme before the talk, so the talk itself may differ.